The discussion of whether a person can truly have free choice or not is one that nearly everyone has an opinion about.
Since in this week’s Torah portion, Netzavim, Moses told the Jewish people that when they were faced with critical decisions such as life or death, and blessings or curses, they should choose life, it is appropriate to address this issue now. In addition, because it is mere days before the High Holidays, it is especially fitting to enter the Holiday season with a better understanding of our relationship with G-d , specifically regarding our choice to practice any religion, even though we may have been born into it.
What is free choice?
There are companies in the tech industry that give their employees free time to work on any product or project that they choose. Is their choice really free? What happens if they are successful? Does the project belong to them? Or to the company? And if they are not successful, will the company allow them to continue wasting company time? Do they really have free time, or is it the company’s time? How do we define free?
If I choose something because I like it, that is not free choice, since something motivated me to choose it; it may be my nature that guided me in a certain direction or perhaps it was my reasoning. Maybe even a friend or – dare I say it – the media that influenced me. I may think that I chose it out of free will, but did I really?
How do I really know who the real me is, and that it was me who made the real free choice?
If I reach into my essence—no frills, no external pressure, no influence—then I know that I reached my true self and I am truly free.
My essence is my soul. My soul is part of G-d. If I connect to G-d, I will be free.
Let me use an analogy to explain. A father who wants to gift a piece of property to his child will not only give the land to the child but will also let them know that this is their lot. This land belongs to them. That it was always intended for them. This is not an afterthought, but rather from the moment of purchase, it was placed in a trust for the sole purpose that the child should have this gift at a certain point in life. All the child has to do is to take ownership of it.
However, if the child doesn’t take ownership and it is just forced on them, although they are the technical owner, they don’t fully take possession of it. To make it one’s own, they have to take it freely. Not just because their father wants to give it to them, but because they understand why it is theirs.
This is what free choice is all about: The recognition that we are connected to something or someone else, whether our parent, our spouse, or G-d. When we make that connection–-soul to soul—we become a free person.